You can't test-drive a remodel. By the time you find out whether a company communicates well or cuts corners, you've usually already signed a contract, and a polished estimate and a friendly first meeting can make almost any contractor look like the right choice. A hiring checklist fixes that by holding every company to the same standards before you commit: credentials, scope, references, communication, and the contract itself.
Here is how to check each one before work starts on a kitchen, bathroom, basement, or whole-home remodel.
- The Checklist at a Glance
- Verify the License, Insurance, and Lead-Safe Certification
- Notice How the First Conversations Go
- Compare the Scope Before You Compare the Price
- Check Reviews, References, and Finished Work
- Read the Contract Before You Sign
- Red Flags That Mean Slow Down
- When the Lowest Bid Is (and Isn't) the Right Choice
- Frequently Asked Questions
The Checklist at a Glance
Before you sign with any remodeling contractor, you should be able to tick every box below. Each one is explained in the sections that follow, and the same list is available as a printable PDF to bring to each estimate meeting.
Credentials
- The contractor's Minnesota license number checks out on the state's lookup, with no disciplinary history you can't explain
- You have certificates of liability and workers' compensation insurance
- For a home built before 1978, the company is an EPA Lead-Safe Certified Firm
- You know who pulls the permits and schedules inspections
The Bids
- Every bid lists the same scope, and you know what each one excludes
- Allowances are realistic for the finishes you actually want
- You know how hidden conditions behind walls get priced and approved
References and Communication
- You've talked to references from projects like yours and seen finished work up close
- You know who your day-to-day contact will be and how often you'll hear from them
The Contract
- The contract spells out scope, materials, price, payment schedule, timeline, and warranty
- Every change has to be a written change order you sign before the work happens
- Payments follow project milestones, not a large sum up front
- If subcontractors or suppliers are involved, the contract includes Minnesota's pre-lien notice
Verify the License, Insurance, and Lead-Safe Certification
The first check is whether the company is legally allowed to do the work. In Minnesota, anyone who contracts directly with a homeowner to do work in more than one skill area, such as framing plus drywall plus finish carpentry, needs a residential building contractor or residential remodeler license from the Minnesota Department of Labor and Industry (DLI). The only exemption is for very small operations: under $15,000 in gross annual residential receipts, and only with a state-issued Certificate of Exemption.
Ask for the license number and look it up yourself. Building contractor licenses start with BC and remodeler licenses with CR. Ours is BC387590. DLI's guide to hiring a contractor points out a distinction many homeowners miss: a contractor registration is not a license. Registered contractors don't have to carry proof of insurance, and they don't pay into the state's Contractor Recovery Fund.
That fund is the practical reason the license matters. If a licensed contractor causes you a loss and you get a final court judgment against them, the fund can reimburse homeowners for documented out-of-pocket costs on owner-occupied Minnesota property. The contractor must have held an active license both when the contract was signed and when the work was done. Hire someone unlicensed and that protection is gone.
Next, ask for certificates of insurance: general liability, and workers' compensation if the company has employees. An uninsured crew member injured on your property can become your problem. A certificate sent straight from the insurance agent is better than a photocopy.
If your home was built before 1978, add one more check. Renovation work that disturbs painted surfaces in those homes falls under the EPA's Renovation, Repair, and Painting rule, which requires a certified firm using lead-safe work practices. That includes many older homes in Minneapolis, St. Paul, and the first-ring suburbs. Honey-Doers is an EPA Lead-Safe Certified Firm, certification NAT-F151615-3.
Finally, ask who handles permits. Requirements vary by city, and a contractor who works in your area should be able to tell you plainly which approvals the job needs and who will schedule the inspections. Get the answer in writing, along with who will be on site for each inspection. Our guide to when a remodel needs a permit covers what usually triggers one.
Notice How the First Conversations Go
How a contractor handles the very first exchange is a preview of the whole project. A quality, experienced contractor listens first, asking about your goals and how you use the space rather than jumping straight to scheduling a walkthrough. Many good companies will give a site-unseen ballpark before booking an on-site appointment. That sets budget expectations on both sides before either one invests real time.
Notice, too, whether calls are returned and questions answered directly. A company that is slow or vague before it has been paid rarely improves once the job is underway.
Before you sign, ask who your main point of contact will be, who oversees the job on site, and how often you'll get updates. Also ask how schedule changes are handled. Inspections, material delays, and conditions behind the walls all move dates, and Minnesota's compressed building season makes spring and summer slots tight. A contractor who explains how they plan around that is more useful than one who promises a fast timeline without saying how.
Compare the Scope Before You Compare the Price
An estimate only means something once you know what it includes. Two proposals for the "same" project can differ by thousands of dollars because they describe different projects. Comparing totals without comparing scope is one of the most common ways homeowners end up frustrated.
Ask each contractor to walk you through how they arrived at their number. You don't need to reveal the competing bids. Most large gaps come down to one of three causes:
- Volume pricing. Some companies compete on price because their business depends on volume, not on repeat and referral clients. A lower number can mean a leaner crew, tighter margins, and less reason to make one project exceptional.
- Exclusions in scope. A bid that looks like a bargain sometimes just leaves something out, such as permit fees, disposal, or a whole phase of the work, and the gap comes back later as a change order.
- Material grade. Cabinetry is the usual example. Two bids can price an identical layout very differently because one specifies stock boxes and the other semi-custom or custom.
Allowances deserve a close look. An allowance is a budget placeholder for something you haven't picked yet, like tile, plumbing fixtures, or lighting. They're normal, especially early in planning, but a low allowance makes a proposal look cheaper while setting up extra cost the moment you choose the finishes you actually want. Ask how each allowance was set and what it buys.
Ask, too, how the contractor handles what nobody can see yet. Opening walls and floors in an older home can turn up water damage, outdated wiring, or framing problems. No honest contractor can promise there won't be surprises. What they can tell you is how a discovery gets documented, priced, and approved by you before the extra work moves forward.
Check Reviews, References, and Finished Work
Specific reviews are worth more than a high star average. Smaller, newer companies sometimes collect vague five-star reviews from friends and family, which is why the rating alone tells you little. Look for reviews that name team members, describe what the client liked about the process, and mention how problems were handled. That level of detail is hard to fake.
Read across many reviews instead of judging on one or two: a theme that keeps coming up is how the company operates. Watch how it responds to criticism, too.
Then ask for references from projects like yours. If you're planning a basement, a past basement client is more useful than a small repair customer. Ask whether the team kept them informed, handled changes clearly, and came back to finish the punch list.
For craftsmanship, look past the style to the details: cabinet alignment, tile layout, trim joints, and transitions between materials. Our project gallery shows that kind of detail, such as the hex-tile floor in this Prior Lake primary bathroom. A company with a long local track record, like the homeowners we've worked with in Prior Lake, also has more reason to protect its name after the job is done.
Read the Contract Before You Sign
The contract should describe the whole job, not just the price. DLI's guidance lists what a Minnesota home improvement contract should contain:
- A detailed summary of the work and a description of the materials
- The total price, or exactly how the price will be calculated
- A payment schedule that makes clear when each payment is due
- Specific timelines, and what happens if the contractor misses them
- A requirement that every change be written up as a change order you sign
If a verbal promise matters to your decision, ask for it in writing. Don't sign an estimate or "authorization" form before you've decided to hire. DLI warns that those forms are usually binding contracts, whatever the salesperson says.
Payment terms deserve particular attention. A reasonable schedule ties payments to milestones, such as signing, rough-in, and completion, rather than collecting most of the cost up front. Ask what each payment covers and what will be in place before it's due.
Change orders are normal. What matters is that you see the cost and schedule impact in writing before the change is made, and here a contractor's track record shows. Across our 254 quoted projects since 2022, 126 finished without a single change order. On all of them combined, change orders added up to 4.3% of the contracted price, counting both work homeowners added and work they took out. It's a fair question for any contractor: how far do your final prices usually move from the quote?
Two Minnesota-specific items belong in the paperwork as well. If the contractor uses subcontractors or suppliers, state lien law (Minn. Stat. § 514.011) requires a pre-lien notice in the written contract. It tells you those parties can file a lien against your home if they go unpaid. Asking for lien waivers as payments are made is how you make sure they were paid. Finally, ask what happens after the main work is done: how the punch list gets finished, and what the warranty covers and for how long.
Red Flags That Mean Slow Down
No single warning sign disqualifies a contractor, but certain patterns deserve a closer look before you go further. DLI's list of warning signs includes contractors who show up unsolicited, use high-pressure sales tactics, require full or substantial payment before work begins, refuse to give a license number or references, or quote an unusually low price.
Suspicious Availability
A contractor who pushes hard for an immediate on-site estimate, or offers to start the week you sign, is telling you something about their schedule. Busy, established remodelers usually qualify a project first, making sure the budget fits the scope, and in Minnesota they're often booked out for weeks or months during the spring and summer rush. Wide-open availability in peak season is worth asking about, not celebrating.
A Vague Contract
A contract that lists a price and little else leaves every gap to be argued about later, and on the cheapest bid those gaps tend to return as change orders.
Watch for patterns rather than single signs. A contractor who's genuinely available this week isn't automatically a bad hire. Rushed scheduling, a thin contract, and slow communication tend to show up together.
When the Lowest Bid Is (and Isn't) the Right Choice
The lowest bid is rarely the right choice, with one honest exception: a real time or budget limit. Even then, the better move is usually to reduce scope or split the project into phases with a reputable contractor rather than taking the cheapest full bid. Otherwise, the lowest number on the table tends to cost the most in the end, through change orders, rushed work, or a company that isn't around to stand behind the job a year later.
If you're weighing a smaller job, our comparison of handyman vs. remodeling contractor covers when each one fits.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many bids should I get before hiring a remodeling contractor?
Three bids from licensed, insured contractors usually give a clear picture of fair pricing. With fewer, it's hard to spot an outlier; with many more, you mostly add decision fatigue.
How do I check a contractor's license in Minnesota?
Ask for the license number and look it up on the Minnesota Department of Labor and Industry's website, or call DLI. Residential building contractor licenses start with BC and remodeler licenses with CR. The lookup also shows any disciplinary action. A registration number, which starts with IR, is not a license.
Is it normal for remodeling bids to vary by thousands of dollars for the same project?
Yes, and it's worth looking into rather than assuming someone is overcharging. Ask each contractor what's driving their number. Most gaps come down to scope, materials, or business model, not dishonesty.
What's a reasonable deposit to pay a contractor before work starts?
The contract should tie payments to project milestones. Be cautious of any contractor who wants full or substantial payment before materials are ordered or work begins. DLI lists that as a warning sign.
What should a remodeling contract include?
At minimum: a detailed scope of work, the materials, the total price or pricing method, a payment schedule, a timeline, warranty terms, and a requirement that every change be a signed, written change order. If the contractor uses subcontractors, Minnesota law also requires a pre-lien notice in the contract.
A good checklist works best on a contractor who's happy to be checked. Honey-Doers starts every project with a transparent, ballpark-first process, and we'll answer the same questions about our own bid that we'd tell you to ask anyone else. For a full list of what to ask at the first meeting, see 19 questions to ask your contractor, or read what to look for in a Minnesota remodeler. Planning a kitchen, bathroom, or basement remodel? When you're ready to put a real bid next to the others, contact our team for an estimate.




